Last Tuesday I attended a talk at the Brookings Institute - a DC based non-profit think tank - titled US
Alberta Energy Relations: A Conversation with Allison Redford. I
attended with the full intention of having a conversation about Tar Sands
extraction and the climate consequences with Premier Allison Redford - the lead
government official from Alberta, Canada. When I arrived I quickly realized that I was
not going to be having a conversation with anyone. In this form of "conversation"
the Brookings Institute asks audience participants to write down their
questions on a card that get passed up, then a woman chooses which questions
get asked and the Chairman of Cambridge Energy Research Association, Daniel Yergin get's to talk to Premier Redford about the question.
![]() |
My viewpoint looking at Premier Redford and Alex Yergin |
According
to the dictionary the definition of conversation is "The informal exchange
of ideas by spoken words." Instead of having a conversation -which by
everyone's connotation implies an exchange of ideas with voices - the Brooking
Institute chose to assault and kick-out anyone who sought to use their voices to have a real
conversation with Premier Allison Redford. By the end of my time at the hearing, I would be assaulted by security guards and removed from the room for attempting a conversation about the climate impacts of tar sands extraction and proliferation. Here's the video and below is my story. Here's a link to a major news outlet that covered "the interruption." Here's a link to the entire conversation via webcast made available by the Brookings Institute.